Skip to content

अध्याय ६ · षष्ठोऽध्यायः

Book VI — Summary

ṣaṣṭho'dhyāyaḥ

A recapitulation. Soul exists and is distinct from body and Nature; release is the end of pain; meditation, posture and duty lead to discrimination, and once it is complete the bondage, which was only ever apparent, falls away.

70 versesSanskrit with translation

An unknotted rope rests beside a still adult observer on a slate stone ledge, a vast olive and ochre landscape beyond in clear silver morning light, effortless distinction and release.

अस्त्यात्मा नास्तित्वसाधनाभावात् ॥ १ ॥

astyātmā nāstitvasādhanābhāvāt || 1 ||

Soul is; for there is no proof that it is not.

From the commentaries (tr. Ballantyne)

Soul really is existent, generically; since we are aware of this, that 'I think;' because there is no evidence to defeat this. Therefore, all that is to be done is to discriminate it [from things in general]. Such is the meaning.

The discrimination of it he establishes by means of two proofs:

Report an error

देहादिव्यतिरिक्तोऽसौ वैचित्र्यात् ॥ २ ॥

dehādivyatirikto'sau vaicitryāt || 2 ||

This [Soul,] is different from the Body, &c.; because of heterogeneousness, [or complete difference between the two].

Report an error

षष्ठीव्यपदेशादपि ॥ ३ ॥

ṣaṣṭhīvyapadeśādapi || 3 ||

Also because it [Soul,] is expressed by means of the sixth [or possessive,] case.

From the commentaries (tr. Ballantyne)

That is to say: Soul is different from Body, &c., also because the learned express it by the possessive case, in such examples as, 'This [is] my body,' 'This [is] my understanding;' for the possessive case would be unaccountable, if there were absolute non-difference [between the Body, or the like, and the Soul, to which it is thus attributed as a possession].

But then, suppose that this, also, is like the expressions, 'The Soul's Thought' [Soul and Thought being identical], 'Ráhu's head' [the trunkless Ráhu being all head], 'The statue's body,' &c. To this he replies:

Report an error

न शिलापुत्रवत्, धर्मिग्राहकमानबाधात् ॥ ४ ॥

na śilāputravat, dharmigrāhakamānabādhāt || 4 ||

It is not as in the case of the statue; because there is [there] a contradiction to the evidence which acquaints us with the thing.

From the commentaries (tr. Ballantyne)

This expression by means of the possessive case, [viz., 'My body' (§ 3)] is not like 'The statue's body,' &c. In such a case as 'The statue's body,' there is a mere fiction; 'for it is contradicted by the evidence which acquaints is with the thing;' [sense being the evidence that there is here no body other than the statue]. But, in such an expression as 'My body,' there is no contradiction by evidence; for the contradiction, by Scripture and other evidences, is only in supposing the Body to be the Soul. Such is the meaning.

Having settled that Soul is different from Body, &c., he settles its emancipation:

Report an error

अत्यन्तदुःखनिवृत्त्या कृतकृत्यता ॥ ५ ॥

atyantaduḥkhanivṛttyā kṛtakṛtyatā || 5 ||

Through the entire cessation of pain there is done what was to be done.

From the commentaries (tr. Ballantyne)

But then, since there is an equality of gain and loss, inasmuch as, through the cessation of Pain there is the ceasing of Pleasure, also, that cannot be Soul's aim. To this he replies:

Report an error

यथा दुःखात् क्लेशः पुरुषस्य, न तथा सुखाभिलाषः ॥ ६ ॥

yathā duḥkhāt kleśaḥ puruṣasya, na tathā sukhābhilāṣaḥ || 6 ||

Not such desire for pleasure is there to Soul, as there is annoyance from Pain.

From the commentaries (tr. Ballantyne)

And so the aversion to Pain, having excluded also the desire for Pleasure, gives rise to a wish for he cessation of Pain simply; so that there is not an equality of gain and loss: [but a clear gain, in the desired release].

He declares that Soul's aim is simply the cessation of Pain; because Pain is, indeed, abundant, in comparison of Pleasure:

Report an error

कुत्रापि कोऽपि सुखीति ॥ ७ ॥

kutrāpi ko'pi sukhīti || 7 ||

For [only] some one, somewhere, is happy.

From the commentaries (tr. Ballantyne)

Among innumerable grasses, trees, brutes, birds, men, &c., very few,—a man, a god, or the like,—are happy: such is the meaning.

Report an error

तदपि दुःखशबलितमिति दुःखपक्षे निक्षिपन्ते विवेचकाः ॥ ८ ॥

tadapi duḥkhaśabalitamiti duḥkhapakṣe nikṣipante vivecakāḥ || 8 ||

It [Pleasure,] is also mixed with Pain, therefore the discriminating throw it to the side of [and reckon it as so much,] Pain.

From the commentaries (tr. Ballantyne)

He rejects the opinion that Soul's aim is not the simple cessation of Pain, but this [cessation] tinctured with Pleasure:

Report an error

सुखलाभाभावादपुरुषार्थत्वामिति चेन्न द्वैविध्यात् ॥ ९ ॥

sukhalābhābhāvādapuruṣārthatvāmiti cenna dvaividhyāt || 9 ||

If you say that this [cessation of Pain] is not Soul's aim, inasmuch as there is no acquisition of Pleasure, then it is not as you say; for there are two kinds [of things desired].

From the commentaries (tr. Ballantyne)

For we see, amongst men, quite a distinct aspiration: [the first,] 'May I be happy;' [the second,] 'May I not be miserable;' [and the latter is our conception of beatitude].

He ponders a doubt:

Report an error

निर्गुणत्वमात्मनोऽसङ्गत्वादिश्रुतेः ॥ १० ॥

nirguṇatvamātmano'saṅgatvādiśruteḥ || 10 ||

The Soul [some one may suggest,] has no quality; for there is Scripture for its being unaccompanied, &c.

From the commentaries (tr. Ballantyne)

Therefore the cessation of Pain, indeed, [a property which does not belong to it,] cannot be Soul's aim: such is the meaning.

He clears up this [doubt]:

Report an error

परमधर्मत्वेऽपि तत्सिद्धिरविवेकात् ॥ ११ ॥

paramadharmatve'pi tatsiddhiravivekāt || 11 ||

Though it [the Pain,] be the property of something else, yet it exists in it [the Soul,] through non-discrimination.

From the commentaries (tr. Ballantyne)

Though qualities, viz., pleasure, pain, &c., belong [only] to the Mind, they exist, i.e., they abide, in the shape of a reflexion, in it, viz., in Soul, 'through non-discrimination,' as the cause, owing to the conjunction of Nature with Soul: such is the meaning. And this has been set forth in the First Book.

The binding of Soul by the qualities [or fetters,] arises from non-discrimination: but from what does non-discrimination arise? With reference to this, he says:

Report an error

अनादिरविवेकः अन्यथा दोषद्वयप्रसक्तेः ॥ १२ ॥

anādiravivekaḥ anyathā doṣadvayaprasakteḥ || 12 ||

Non-discrimination [of Soul from Nature] is beginningless; because, otherwise, two objections would present themselves.

From the commentaries (tr. Ballantyne)

For, had it a beginning, then, if [first,] it arose quite spontaneously, bondage might befall even the liberated; and, if [secondly,] it were produced by Desert, &c., there would be a regressus in infinitum, inasmuch as we should have to search for another [previous instance of] non-discrimination, to stand as the cause of [that] Desert, &c., also: such is the meaning.

And then, if it be without beginning, it must be everlasting. To this he replies:

Report an error

न नित्यः स्यादात्मवदन्यथानुच्छित्तिः ॥ १३ ॥

na nityaḥ syādātmavadanyathānucchittiḥ || 13 ||

It [non-discrimination, cannot be everlasting [in the same manner] as the soul is; else, it could not be cut short, [as we affirm that it can be].

From the commentaries (tr. Ballantyne)

It is not everlasting, indivisible, and beginningless, in the same way as the soul is; but it is beginningless, in the shape of an on-flow [which may be stopped]. For, otherwise, the cutting short of a beginningless entity would, as is established by Scripture, be unfeasible, [though the beginningless antecedent non-entity of a given jar may be readily understood to terminate, on the production of the jar]. Such is the meaning.

Having stated the cause of [Soul's] Bondage, he states the cause of Liberation:

Report an error

प्रतिनियतकारण नाश्यत्वमस्य ध्वान्तवत् ॥ १४ ॥

pratiniyatakāraṇa nāśyatvamasya dhvāntavat || 14 ||

It [Bondage,] is annihilable by the alloted cause, [viz., discrimination of Soul from Nature]; as darkness is [annihilable by the allotted cause, viz., Light].

Report an error

अत्रापि प्रतिनियमोऽन्वयव्यतिरेकात् ॥ १५ ॥

atrāpi pratiniyamo'nvayavyatirekāt || 15 ||

Here, also, [viz., in the case of Bondage and Discrimination, as in the case of Darkness and Light,] there is allotment, [as is proved] both by positive and negative consociation; [Liberation taking place where Discrimination is, and not where it is not].

From the commentaries (tr. Ballantyne)

He reminds [us] of what was mentioned in the first Book, viz., that Bondage cannot be innate, &c:

Report an error

प्रकारान्तरासम्भवादविवेक एव बन्धः ॥ १६ ॥

prakārāntarāsambhavādaviveka eva bandhaḥ || 16 ||

Since it cannot be [accounted for] in any other way, it is non-discrimination alone that is [the cause of] Bondage, [which cannot be innate].

From the commentaries (tr. Ballantyne)

'Bondage' here means the cause of Bondage, named the conjunction of pain. The rest is plain.

But then, since liberation, also, from its being a product, is liable to destruction, Bondage should take place over again. To this he replies:

Report an error

न मुक्तस्य पुनर्बन्धयोगोऽप्यनावृत्ति श्रुतेः ॥ १७ ॥

na muktasya punarbandhayogo'pyanāvṛtti śruteḥ || 17 ||

Further, Bondage does not again attach to the liberated; because there is Scripture for its non-recurrence.

Report an error

अपुरुषार्थत्वमन्यथा ॥ १८ ॥

apuruṣārthatvamanyathā || 18 ||

Else, it [liberation,] would not be the Soul's aim, [which it is].

From the commentaries (tr. Ballantyne)

He states the reason why this is not Soul's aim:

Report an error

अविशेषापत्तिरुभयोः ॥ १९ ॥

aviśeṣāpattirubhayoḥ || 19 ||

What happened to both would be alike, [if liberation were perishable].

From the commentaries (tr. Ballantyne)

That is to say: there would be no difference between the two, the liberated and the bound; because of their being alike liable to future bondage; and, therefore, such [perishable emancipation] is not Soul's aim, [but emancipation final and complete].

But then, in that case, if you acknowledge that there is a distinction between the bond and the free, how is it that you have asserted [Book I., § 19,] the eternal freedom [of all souls alike]? To this he replies:

Report an error

मुक्तिरन्तराय ध्वस्तेर्न परः ॥ २० ॥

muktirantarāya dhvasterna paraḥ || 20 ||

Liberation is nothing other than the removal of the obstacle [to the Soul's recognition of itself as free].

From the commentaries (tr. Ballantyne)

But then, in that case, since Bondage and Liberation are unreal, Liberation must be contradictory to the texts, &c., which set forth what is Soul's aim, [as some positive and real acquisition, not merely the removal of a screen]; to which he replies:

Report an error

तत्राप्यविरोधः ॥ २१ ॥

tatrāpyavirodhaḥ || 21 ||

Even in that case, there is no contradiction.

From the commentaries (tr. Ballantyne)

That is to say: 'even in that case,' i.e., even if Liberation consists [only] in the removal of an obstacle, there is no contradiction in its being Soul's aim.

But then, if Liberation be merely the removal of an obstacle, then it should be accomplished through mere hearing [of the error which stands in the way]; just as a piece of gold on one's neck, [which one has sought for in vain, while it was] withheld from one by ignorance [of the fact that it has been tied round one's neck with a string], is attained, [on one's hearing where it is]. To this he replies:

Report an error

अधिकारित्रैविध्यान्न नियमः ॥ २२ ॥

adhikāritraividhyānna niyamaḥ || 22 ||

This [attainment of Liberation, on the mere hearing of the truth,] is no necessity; for there are three sorts of those competent [to apprehend the truth; but not all are qualified to appropriate it, on merely hearing it].

From the commentaries (tr. Ballantyne)

He mentions that not mere hearing alone is seen to be the cause of knowledge, but that there are others, also:

Report an error

दार्ढ्यार्थमुत्तरेषां ॥ २३ ॥

dārḍhyārthamuttareṣāṃ || 23 ||

Of others [viz., other means besides hearing] for the sake of confirmation, [there is need].

From the commentaries (tr. Ballantyne)

He speaks of these same other means:

Report an error

स्थिरसुखमासनमिति न नियमः ॥ २४ ॥

sthirasukhamāsanamiti na niyamaḥ || 24 ||

There is no [absolute] necessity that what is steady and promoting ease should be a [particular] posture, [such as any of those referred to in Book III., § 34].

From the commentaries (tr. Ballantyne)

That is to say: there is no necessity that a 'posture' should be the 'lotus-posture,' or the like; because whatever is steady and promotes ease is a [suitable] 'posture.'

He states the principal means [of Concentration]:

Report an error

ध्यानं निर्विषयं मनः ॥ २५ ॥

dhyānaṃ nirviṣayaṃ manaḥ || 25 ||

Mind without an object is Meditation.

From the commentaries (tr. Ballantyne)

That is to say: what Internal Organ is void of any modification, that is 'Meditation,' i.e., Concentration, in the shape of exclusion of the modifications of Intellect: by reason of the identity [here,] of effect and cause, the word 'cause' is employed for 'effect.' For it will be declared how Meditation effects this [exclusion of the modifications of Intellect].

But then, since Soul is alike, whether there be Concentration or Non-concentration, what have we to do with concentration? Having pondered this doubt, he clears it up:

Report an error

उभयथाप्यविशेषश्चेन्नैवमुपरागनिरोधाद्विशेषः ॥ २६ ॥

ubhayathāpyaviśeṣaścennaivamuparāganirodhādviśeṣaḥ || 26 ||

If you say that even both ways there is no difference, it is not so: there is a difference, through the excluion [in the one case,] of the tinge [of reflected pain which exists in the other case].

From the commentaries (tr. Ballantyne)

But how can there exist a tinge in that which is unassociated [with anything whatever, as Soul is alleged to be]? To this he replies:

Report an error

निस्सङ्गेऽप्युपरागोऽविवेकात् ॥ २७ ॥

nissaṅge'pyuparāgo'vivekāt || 27 ||

Though it [Soul,] be unassociated, still there is a tingeing [reflexionally,] through Non-discrimination.

From the commentaries (tr. Ballantyne)

That is to say: though there is not a real tinge in that which is unassociated [with tincture, or anything else], still there is, as it were, a tinge; hence the tinge is treated as simply a reflexion, by those who discriminate the tinge [from the Soul, which it delusively seems to belong to].

He explains this same:

Report an error

जपास्फटिकयोरिव नोपरागः किन्त्वभिमानः ॥ २८ ॥

japāsphaṭikayoriva noparāgaḥ kintvabhimānaḥ || 28 ||

As is the case with the Hibiscus and the crystal [Book I., § 19, c.], there is not a tinge, but a fancy [that there is such].

From the commentaries (tr. Ballantyne)

He states the means of excluding the aforesaid tinge:

Report an error

ध्यानधारणाभ्यास वैराग्यादिभिः तन्निरोधः ॥ २९ ॥

dhyānadhāraṇābhyāsa vairāgyādibhiḥ tannirodhaḥ || 29 ||

It [viz.,the aforesaid tinge,] is debarred by Meditation, Restraint, Practice, Apathy, &c.

From the commentaries (tr. Ballantyne)

He shows the means settled by the ancient teachers, in regard to the exclusion—through Meditation, &c., lodged in the Mind,—of the tingeing of Soul:

Report an error

लयविक्षेपयोर्व्यावृत्त्येत्याचार्याः ॥ ३० ॥

layavikṣepayorvyāvṛttyetyācāryāḥ || 30 ||

It is by the exclusion of dissolution and distraction, say the teachers.

From the commentaries (tr. Ballantyne)

That is to say: through the removal, by means of meditation, &c., of the Mind's condition of [being dissolved in] Sleep, and condition of [waking] Certainty, &c., there takes place also the exclusion of the tingeing of Soul by the condition; because, on the exclusion of any [real] object, there is the exclusion also of its reflexion: so say the ancient teachers.

He states that there is no compulsion that Meditation, &c., should take place in caves and such places:

Report an error

न स्थाननियमः चित्तप्रसादात् ॥ ३१ ॥

na sthānaniyamaḥ cittaprasādāt || 31 ||

There is no rule about localities; for it is from tranquillity of Mind.

From the commentaries (tr. Ballantyne)

That is to say: Meditation, or the like, results simply 'from tranquillity of Mind.' Therefore, such a place as a cave is not indispensable for it.

The discussion of Liberation is completed. Now, with an eye to the unchangeableness of Soul, he handles compendiously the cause of the world:

Report an error

प्रतेराद्योपादानतान्येषां कार्यत्वश्रुतेः ॥ ३२ ॥

praterādyopādānatānyeṣāṃ kāryatvaśruteḥ || 32 ||

Nature is the primal material; for there is Scripture [to the effect] that the others are products.

From the commentaries (tr. Ballantyne)

That is to say: since we learn, from Scripture, that Mind, &c., are products, Nature is established under the character of the radical cause of these.

But then, let Soul be the material. To this he replies:

Report an error

नित्यत्वेऽपि नात्मनो योग्यत्वाभावात् ॥ ३३ ॥

nityatve'pi nātmano yogyatvābhāvāt || 33 ||

Not to Soul does this [viz., the material of the world,] belong, though it be eternal; because of its want of suitableness.

From the commentaries (tr. Ballantyne)

That is to say: suitableness to act as material implies possession of qualities, and the being associable: [and,] by reason of the absence of both of these, Soul, though eternal, [and, therefore, no product,] cannot serve as material.

But then, since, from such Scriptural texts as, 'Many creatures have been produced from Soul,' we may gather the fact that Soul is a cause, the assertions of an illusory creation, &c., ought to be accepted. Having pondered this adverse suggestion, he replies:

Report an error

श्रुतिविरोधान्न कुतर्कापसदस्यात्मलाभः ॥ ३४ ॥

śrutivirodhānna kutarkāpasadasyātmalābhaḥ || 34 ||

The despicable sophist does not gain [a correct apprehension of] Soul; because of the contradictoriness [of his notions] to Scripture.

From the commentaries (tr. Ballantyne)

That is to say: the various views, in regard to Soul's being a cause, which are conceivable are, all, opposed to Scripture; therefore, the lowest of the bad reasoners, and others, who are accepters thereof, have no knowledge of the nature of Soul. Hence it is to be understood that those, also, [e.g., the Naiyáyikas,] who assert that Soul is the substance of the qualities Pleasure, Pain, &c., are quite illogical; these, also, have no correct knowledge of Soul. And, if it be asserted that Soul is a cause [of the world], just as the sky is the recipient cause of the clouds, &c., [and stands, towards it, in the relation of a cause, in so far as, without the room afforded by it, these could not exist], then we do not object to that; for, what we deny is only that there is transformation [of soul, as material, into the world, as product].

Since we see, that, in the case of things motionless, locomotive, &c., the material cause is nothing else than earth, &c., how can Nature be the material of all? To this he replies:

Report an error

पारम्पर्येऽपि प्रधानानुवृत्तिरणुवत् ॥ ३५ ॥

pāramparye'pi pradhānānuvṛttiraṇuvat || 35 ||

Though but mediately [the cause of products], Nature is inferred [as the ultimate cause of the intermediate causes,]; just as are Atoms, [by the Vaiśeshikas].

Report an error

सर्वत्र कार्यदर्शनात् विभुत्वं ॥ ३६ ॥

sarvatra kāryadarśanāt vibhutvaṃ || 36 ||

It [Nature,] is all-pervading; because [its] products are seen everywhere.

From the commentaries (tr. Ballantyne)

But then, only if it be limited, can it be said that, 'Wherever a product arises, there does it [Nature,] go [or act];' [for what is unlimited] and fills all space, can find no other space to move into]. To this he replies:

Report an error

गतियोगेऽप्याद्यकारणताहानिरणुवत् ॥ ३७ ॥

gatiyoge'pyādyakāraṇatāhāniraṇuvat || 37 ||

Though motion may attach to it, this does not destroy its character as ultimate cause; just as is the case with Atoms.

From the commentaries (tr. Ballantyne)

'Motion' means action. Though it be present, this does not prevent its [Nature's,] being the radical cause; just as is the case with the earthy and other Atoms, according to the opinion of the Vaiśeshikas: such is the meaning.

Report an error

प्रसिद्धाधिक्यं प्रधानस्य न नियमः ॥ ३८ ॥

prasiddhādhikyaṃ pradhānasya na niyamaḥ || 38 ||

Nature is something in addition to the notorious [nine Substances of the Naiyáyikas]: it is no matter of necessity [that there should be precisely nine].

From the commentaries (tr. Ballantyne)

And the argument, here, is the Scriptural declaration, that eight [of the pretended primitive substances] are products: such is the import.

Report an error

सत्त्वादीनामतद्धर्मत्वं तद्रूपत्वात् ॥ ३९ ॥

sattvādīnāmataddharmatvaṃ tadrūpatvāt || 39 ||

Purity and the others are not properties of it [viz., Nature]; because they are its essence.

From the commentaries (tr. Ballantyne)

That is to say: Purity and the other Qualities are not properties of Nature; because they are what constitutes Nature.

He determines the motive of Nature's energizing; since, if we held the energizing to be without a motive, Emancipation would be inexplicable:

Report an error

अनुपभोगेऽपि पुमर्थं सृष्टिः प्रधानस्योष्ट्रकुङ्कुमवहनवत् ॥ ४० ॥

anupabhoge'pi pumarthaṃ sṛṣṭiḥ pradhānasyoṣṭrakuṅkumavahanavat || 40 ||

Nature, though it does not enjoy [the results of its own energizing], creates for the sake of Soul; like a cart's carrying saffron, [for the use of its master. See Book III., § 58].

From the commentaries (tr. Ballantyne)

He states the concomitant cause of diversified creation:

Report an error

कर्मवैचित्र्यात्सृष्टिवैचित्र्यं ॥ ४१ ॥

karmavaicitryātsṛṣṭivaicitryaṃ || 41 ||

The diversity of creation is in consequence of the diversity of Desert.

From the commentaries (tr. Ballantyne)

But then, granting that creation is due to Nature, yet whence is destruction? For a couple of opposite results cannot belong to one and the same cause. To this he replies:

Report an error

साम्यवैषम्याभ्यां कार्यद्वयं ॥ ४२ ॥

sāmyavaiṣamyābhyāṃ kāryadvayaṃ || 42 ||

The two results are through equipoise and the reverse of equipoise.

From the commentaries (tr. Ballantyne)

Nature is the triad of Qualities, viz., Purity, &c.; and their 'reverse of equipoise' is their aggregation in excess or defect; the absence of this [reverse of equipoise] is 'equipoise:' through these two causes two opposite results, in the shape of creation and destruction, arise from one and the same: such is the meaning.

But then, since it is Nature's attribute to create, there should be the mundane state, even after [the discriminative] knowledge, [which, it is alleged, puts an end to it]. To this he replies:

Report an error

विमुक्तबोधान्न सृष्टिः प्रधानस्य लोकवत् ॥ ४३ ॥

vimuktabodhānna sṛṣṭiḥ pradhānasya lokavat || 43 ||

Since [or when,] the emancipated has understood [that he never was really otherwise], Nature does not create; just as, in the world, [a minister does not toil,when the king's purpose has been accomplished].

From the commentaries (tr. Ballantyne)

But then, Nature does not rest from creating; for we see the mundane condition of the ignorant: and so, since Nature goes on creating, to the emancipated, also, Bondage may come again. To this he replies:

Report an error

नान्योपसर्पणेऽपि मुक्तोपभोगः निमित्ताभावात् ॥ ४४ ॥

nānyopasarpaṇe'pi muktopabhogaḥ nimittābhāvāt || 44 ||

Even though it [Nature,] may invade others [with its creative influences], the emancipated does not experience, in consequence of the absence of a concurrent cause, [e.g., Non-discrimination, in the absence of which there is no reason why the emancipated should be subjected to Nature's invasion].

From the commentaries (tr. Ballantyne)

But then, this arrangement could be possible then, [only] if there were a multiplicity of souls: but that is quite excluded by the text of the non-duality of Soul. Having pondered this doubt, he says:

Report an error

पुरुषबहुत्वं व्यवस्थातः ॥ ४५ ॥

puruṣabahutvaṃ vyavasthātaḥ || 45 ||

The multeity of Soul [is proved] by the distribution [announced by the Veda itself].

From the commentaries (tr. Ballantyne)

That is to say: the multeity of Soul is proved, absolutely, by the distribution of Bondage and Emancipation mentioned in such Scriptural texts as, 'Whoso understand this, these are immortal, while others experience only sorrow.'

But then, the distribution of Bondage and Liberation may be through the difference of adjunct. To this he replies:

Report an error

उपाधिश्चेत् तत्सिद्धौ पुनर्द्वैतं ॥ ४६ ॥

upādhiścet tatsiddhau punardvaitaṃ || 46 ||

If [you acknowledge] an adjunct [of Soul], then, on its being established, there is duality, [upsetting the dogma founded on in § 44].

From the commentaries (tr. Ballantyne)

But then, the adjuncts, moreover, consist of 'Ignorance,' [which, according to the Vedánta, is no reality]; so that by these there is no detriment to [the Vedántíc dogma of] non-duality. With reference to this doubt, he says:

Report an error

द्वाभ्यामपि प्रमाणविरोधः ॥ ४७ ॥

dvābhyāmapi pramāṇavirodhaḥ || 47 ||

Even by the two the authority is contradicted.

From the commentaries (tr. Ballantyne)

Thst is to say: even by acknowledging the two, viz., Soul and Ignorance, a contradiction is constituted to the text, [which is alleged as] the authority for non-duality.

He states another couple of objections, also:

Report an error

द्वाभ्यामप्यविरोधान्नपूर्वमुत्तरं च साधाकाभावात् ॥ ४८ ॥

dvābhyāmapyavirodhānnapūrvamuttaraṃ ca sādhākābhāvāt || 48 ||

The primā facie view [of the Vedánta] is not [to be allowed any force, as an objection]; because, by [admitting] two, [viz., Soul and Ignorance], there is no opposition [to our own dualistic theory of Soul and Nature]: and the subsequent [dogma, viz., that one single Soul is the only reality, is not to be allowed]; because of the non-existence of a proof, [which, if it did exist, would, along with Soul, constitute a duality].

From the commentaries (tr. Ballantyne)

But then, Soul will be demonstrated by its self-manifestation. To this he replies:

Report an error

प्रकाशतस्तत्सिद्धौ कर्मकर्तृविरोधः ॥ ४९ ॥

prakāśatastatsiddhau karmakartṛvirodhaḥ || 49 ||

[And,] in its [Soul's,] being demonstrated by the light [of itself as you Vedántís say it is], there is the [unreconciled] opposition of patient and agent [in one, which is a contradiction].

From the commentaries (tr. Ballantyne)

That is to say: if Soul be demonstrated by the light which Soul consists of, there is the 'opposition of patient and agent' [in one].

But then, there is no contradiction [here,] between patient and agent; because it [the Soul], through the property of light which is lodged in it, can, itself, furnish the relation to itself; just as the Vaiśeshikas declare, that, through the intelligence lodged in it, it is, itself, object to itself. To this he replies:

Report an error

जडव्यावृत्तो जडं प्रकाशयति चिद्रूपः ॥ ५० ॥

jaḍavyāvṛtto jaḍaṃ prakāśayati cidrūpaḥ || 50 ||

This [Soul], in the shape of Thought, discrepant from the non-intelligent, reveals the non-intelligent.

From the commentaries (tr. Ballantyne)

But then, in that case, if duality be established in accordance with proofs, &c., what becomes of the Scriptural text declaring non-duality? To this he replies:

Report an error

न श्रुतिविरोधो रागिणां वेराग्याय तत्सिद्धेः ॥ ५१ ॥

na śrutivirodho rāgiṇāṃ verāgyāya tatsiddheḥ || 51 ||

There is no contradiction to Scripture [in our view]; because that [text of Scripture which seems to assert absolute non-duality] is [intended] to produce apathy in those who have desires, [and who would be better for believing in 'the nothingness of the things of time'].

From the commentaries (tr. Ballantyne)

He tells us that the assertors of non-duality are to be shunned, not only for the reason above mentioned, but, also, because of the non-existence of evidence to convince us that the world is unreal:

Report an error

जगत्सत्यत्वमदुष्टकरणजन्यत्वम् बाधकाभावात् ॥ ५२ ॥

jagatsatyatvamaduṣṭakaraṇajanyatvam bādhakābhāvāt || 52 ||

The world is real; because it results from an unobjectionable cause, and because there is [in Scripture,] no debarrer [of this view of the matter].

From the commentaries (tr. Ballantyne)

We see, in the world, that no reality belongs to dream-objects, or to the [fancied] yellowness of [invariably white] conch-shells, and the like; inasmuch as these are results of the internal organ, &c., when [not normal, but] injured by [i.e., under the injurious influence of] Sleep, &c.: and this is not [the state of things] in the [waking] Universe, in which Mind is the first, [according to Book I., § 71].

He declares that the Universe is real, not merely in its existent state [at any given instant], but, also, always:

Report an error

प्रकारान्तरासंभवात्सदुत्पत्तिः ॥ ५३ ॥

prakārāntarāsaṃbhavātsadutpattiḥ || 53 ||

Since it cannot be [accounted for] in any other way, manifestation [of whatever is manifested] is of what is real, [i.e., of what previously existed].

From the commentaries (tr. Ballantyne)

That is to say: since, through the aforesaid reasons, it is impossible that the unreal should come into existence, what does come into existence, or is manifested, is what really existed [previously,] in a subtile form.

Though [it is declared that] the being the agent and the being the experiencer belong to diverse subjects, be asserts the distribution [of agency to Self-consciousness, and of experience to Soul,] by two aphorisms:

Report an error

अहङ्कारः कर्ता न पुरुषः ॥ ५४ ॥

ahaṅkāraḥ kartā na puruṣaḥ || 54 ||

Self-consciousness, not Soul, is the agent.

Report an error

चिदवसाना भुक्तिः तत्कर्मार्जितत्वात् ॥ ५५ ॥

cidavasānā bhuktiḥ tatkarmārjitatvāt || 55 ||

Experience ceases at [discrimination of] Soul, [as being quite distinct from Nature]; since it arises from its [Soul's,] Desert, [which is not, really, Soul's, but which, while Non-discrimination lasts, is made over to Soul; just as the fruits of the acts of a king's ministers are made over to the king].

From the commentaries (tr. Ballantyne)

He shows the reason for what was stated before, viz., that cessation of action does not result from enterings into the world of Brahmá:

Report an error

चन्द्रादिलोकेप्यावृत्तिः निमित्तसद्भावात् ॥ ५६ ॥

candrādilokepyāvṛttiḥ nimittasadbhāvāt || 56 ||

Even in the world of the moon, &c., there is return [to munane existence]; because of there really being a cause [of such return].

From the commentaries (tr. Ballantyne)

'A cause,' viz., Non-discrimination, Desert, &c.

But then, through the counsels of the persons dwelling in these various [supermundane] worlds, there ought to be no return [to mundane existence]. To this he replies:

Report an error

लोकस्य नोपदेशात् सिद्धिः पूर्ववत् ॥ ५७ ॥

lokasya nopadeśāt siddhiḥ pūrvavat || 57 ||

Not by the counsel of [supermundane] people is there effectuation [of Emancipation]; just as in the former case, [the case, viz., of counsel given by mundane instructors].

From the commentaries (tr. Ballantyne)

But, in that case, what becomes of the text that there no return from the world of Brahmá? To this he replies:

Report an error

पाराम्पर्येण तत्सिद्धौ विमुक्तिश्रुतिः ॥ ५८ ॥

pārāmparyeṇa tatsiddhau vimuktiśrutiḥ || 58 ||

There is Scripture [declaratory] of Emancipation, [on going to the world of Brahmá]; this [Emancipation] being effected [more readily in that world than in this, but only] by intermediacy [of the appropriate means].

From the commentaries (tr. Ballantyne)

He alleges the Scriptural text of Soul's going [to the locality where it is to experience], even though it be all-filling, [and can, therefore, have no place into which to move]:

Report an error

गतिश्रुतेश्च व्यापकत्वेऽपि उपाधियोगात् भोगदेशकाललाभः व्योमवत् ॥ ५९ ॥

gatiśruteśca vyāpakatve'pi upādhiyogāt bhogadeśakālalābhaḥ vyomavat || 59 ||

And, in accordance with the text of its 'going,' though it [Soul,] is all-pervading, yet, in time, it reaches its place of experience [or body], through conjunction with an adjunct; as in the case of Space.

From the commentaries (tr. Ballantyne)

For, as Space, though it is all-pervading, is spoken of as moving to some particular place, in consequence of its conjunction with an adjunct, such as a jar, [when we say 'the space occupied by the jar is moved to the place to which the jar is carried'], just so is it [here].

He expounds the statement, that the site of experience [the body,] is formed through the superintendence of the experiencer, [Soul]:

Report an error

अनधिष्ठितस्य पूतिभावप्रसङ्गान्न तत्सिद्धिः ॥ ६० ॥

anadhiṣṭhitasya pūtibhāvaprasaṅgānna tatsiddhiḥ || 60 ||

This [constitution of a body] is not accomplished in the case of what is [organic matter] not superintended [by Soul]; because we find putrefaction [in organic matter where Soul is absent].

From the commentaries (tr. Ballantyne)

But then, let the construction of a site of experience [or a body,] for Experiencers [i.e., Souls,] take place without any superintendence at all, through Desert. To this he replies:

Report an error

अदृष्टद्वाराचेदसम्बद्धस्य तदसम्भवाज्जलादिवदङ्कुरे ॥ ६१ ॥

adṛṣṭadvārācedasambaddhasya tadasambhavājjalādivadaṅkure || 61 ||

If you say that [independently of any superintendence,] it is through Desert [that a Body is formed, it is not so]; since what is unconnected [with the matter to be operated upon] is incompetent thereto; as is the case with [unapplied] water, &c., in respect of a plant.

From the commentaries (tr. Ballantyne)

That is to say: because it is impossible that Desert, which is not directly conjoined with the semen and other [elements of the Body] , should operate through Soul, in the construction of the Body, &c.; just as it is for water, &c., unconnected with the seed, to operate through tillage, &c., in the production of a plant.

According to the system of the Vaiśeshikas and others, it is settled that Soul is the superintendent, [in the construction of the Body], in virtue of its being conjoined with Desert. But he tells us, that, in his own doctrine, since Desert, &c., are not properties of Soul, the Soul cannot, through these, be the cause [of the Body]:

Report an error

निर्गुणत्वात्तदसम्भवादहङ्कार धर्माते ॥ ६२ ॥

nirguṇatvāttadasambhavādahaṅkāra dharmāte || 62 ||

For this is impossible [viz., that the Soul should, through its Desert, &c., be the cause of Body]; because it has no qualities for these [viz., Desert, &c.,] are properties of Self-consciousness, [not of Soul].

From the commentaries (tr. Ballantyne)

And so, in our opinion, it is settled that Soul superintends [in the causing of the Body,] quite directly, by conjunction simply, without reference to anything intermediate: such is the import.

But, if Soul be all-pervading, then the limitedness of the living soul, which is set forth in Scripture, is unfounded. To repel this doubt, he says:

Report an error

विशिष्टस्य जीवत्वमन्वयव्यतिरेकात् ॥ ६३ ॥

viśiṣṭasya jīvatvamanvayavyatirekāt || 63 ||

The nature of a living soul belongs to that which is qualified, [not to soul devoid of qualities, as is proved] by direct and indirect argument.

From the commentaries (tr. Ballantyne)

To be a living soul is the being possessed of the vital airs; and this is the character of the soul distinguished by peraonality, not of pure Soul, [which is unlimited].

Desiring, now, to set forth the difference between the products of Mind [or the Great Principle,] and of Self-consciousness, he first states the products of Self-consciousness:

Report an error

अहङ्कारकर्त्रधीना कार्यसिद्धिर्नेश्वराधीना प्रमाणाभावात् ॥ ६४ ॥

ahaṅkārakartradhīnā kāryasiddhirneśvarādhīnā pramāṇābhāvāt || 64 ||

The effectuation of works is dependent on the agent Self-consciousness, not dependent on a Lord, [such as is feigned by the Vaiśeshikas]; because there is no proof [of the reality of such].

From the commentaries (tr. Ballantyne)

By this aphorism are set forth, as are also established by Scripture and the Legal Institutes, the creative and the destructive agencies of Brahmá and Rudra [respectively], owing to their adjunct, Self-consciousness, [or peronality].

But then, grant that Self-consciousness is the maker of the others, still who is the maker of Self-consciousness? to this he replies:

Report an error

अदृष्टोद्भूतिवत्समानत्वं ॥ ६५ ॥

adṛṣṭodbhūtivatsamānatvaṃ || 65 ||

It is the same as in the arising of Desert.

From the commentaries (tr. Ballantyne)

Just as, at the creations, &c., the manifestation of Desert, which sets Nature energizing, results solely from the particular time,—since, if we were to suppose other Desert as the instigator of this, we should have an infinite regress,—just so Self-consciousness arises from time alone. as the cause; but there is not another maker thereof, also: thus, the two [cases] are alike: such is the meaning.

Report an error

महतोऽन्यत् ॥ ६६ ॥

mahato'nyat || 66 ||

The rest is from Mind, [the Great Principle].

From the commentaries (tr. Ballantyne)

What is other than the products of Self-consciousness [or personality], viz., Creation, &c., that, viz., Preservation, &c., results from the Great Principle alone; because, inasmuch as it consists of pure Goodness, having no Conceit, Passion, &c., it is moved solely by benevolence towards others: such is the meaning. And by this aphorism is established the character, as Preserver, of Vishṇu, owing to the Great Principle, as adjunct [of the soul, which, without adjunct, would neither create, preserve, nor destroy (see § 64)].

It has been stated, before, that the relation of Nature and Soul, as experienced and experiencer, is caused by Non-discrimination [of the one from the other]. Here, what is Non-discrimination, itself, caused by? With reference to this doubt, he states that all philosophers reject, in common, the doubt whether we should have an infinite regress, on the supposition of a stream of Non-discrimination; because this [regress] is valid; [since an infinite regress which is in conformity with the truth is no sound cause of objection]:

Report an error

कर्मनिमित्तः प्रकृतेः स्वस्वामिभावोऽप्यनादिः बीजाङ्कुरवत् ॥ ६७ ॥

karmanimittaḥ prakṛteḥ svasvāmibhāvo'pyanādiḥ bījāṅkuravat || 67 ||

The relation of possession and possessor, also, if attributed [as it is by some,] to Desert, in the case of Nature [and Soul], like [the relation of] seed and plant, [which takes the shape of an infinite regress of alternants], is beginningless.

Report an error

अविवेकनिमित्तो वा पञ्चशिखः ॥ ६८ ॥

avivekanimitto vā pañcaśikhaḥ || 68 ||

Or [the case is, likewise, one of infinite regress,] if it [the relation between Nature and Soul,] be attributed to Non-discrimination [of Soul from Nature], as Panchaśikha [holds].

Report an error

लिङ्गशरीरनिमित्तक इति सनन्दनाचार्यः ॥ ६९ ॥

liṅgaśarīranimittaka iti sanandanācāryaḥ || 69 ||

[The case is the same,] if, as the teacher Sanandana does, we attribute it [the relation between Nature and Soul,] to the Subtile Body, [which, in the shape of its elemental causes, attends Soul, even during the periodical annihilations of the world].

From the commentaries (tr. Ballantyne)

He sums up the import of the declarations of the Institute:

Report an error

तत्त्व समाससूत्राणि ॥ ७० ॥

tattva samāsasūtrāṇi || 70 ||

Be that the one way, or the other, the cutting short thereof [viz., of the relation between Nature and Soul,] is Soul's aim; the cutting short thereof is Soul's aim.

Report an error

Illustration: Verse & Place · AI-generated with ChatGPT (Generated for this project). Translation: James R. Ballantyne, The Sánkhya Aphorisms of Kapila, 3rd ed., ed. Fitzedward Hall, London, 1885 (public domain).